Retrosheet


West All Stars(W) (ASW) 4 East All Stars(E) (ASE) 1

SABR Article

Game played on Sunday, August 18, 1946 (D) at Comiskey Park I, Chicago IL
All-Star game

East All Stars(E)                   0 0 0  0 0 0  0 1 0   -   1  4  3
West All Stars(W)                   0 0 0  2 2 0  0 0 x   -   4  7  1

BATTING

East All Stars(E)                    AB   R   H  RBI    BB  SO    PO  A
Henry Kimbro cf                       4   0   0    0     0   0     2   0
Larry Doby 2b                         3   0   1    1     1   1     3   4
Howard Easterling 3b                  4   0   0    0     0   1     0   0
Buck Leonard 1b                       4   0   1    0     0   0     5   1
Monte Irvin lf                        4   0   1    0     0   1     0   0
Josh Gibson c                         3   0   0    0     1   1     5   4
Gene Benson rf                        3   0   0    0     0   0     1   0
Silvio Garcia ss                      1   0   0    0     0   0     5   3
  Murray Watkins ph                   0   1   0    0     0   0     0   0
  Leon Day p                          0   0   0    0     0   0     0   0
Barney Brown p                        1   0   0    0     0   0     1   0
  Bill Byrd p                         1   0   0    0     0   1     0   2
  Jonas Gaines p                      0   0   0    0     0   0     1   1
  Patricio Scantlebury ph             1   0   1    0     0   0     0   0
  Tommy Butts pr, ss                  0   0   0    0     0   0     1   1
Totals                               29   1   4    1     2   5    24  16

FIELDING -
E: 3.  Gene Benson, Silvio Garcia 2. 

BATTING -
HBP:  Silvio Garcia, Murray Watkins. 
GDP:  Gene Benson. 
Team LOB:  5


West All Stars(W)                    AB   R   H  RBI    BB  SO    PO  A
Artie Wilson ss                       4   1   1    0     0   1     5   5
Archie Ware 1b                        2   0   0    0     0   0     8   0
Sam Jethroe cf                        3   1   0    0     0   0     3   1
Piper Davis 2b                        3   1   1    1     1   1     2   8
Willie Grace rf                       4   1   3    0     0   0     1   0
Alex Radcliff 3b                      3   0   0    0     0   3     0   0
Cowan Hyde lf                         3   0   2    1     0   0     1   1
Quincy Trouppe c                      1   0   0    0     2   0     7   0
Felix Evans p                         1   0   0    0     0   0     0   0
  Dan Bankhead p                      1   0   0    0     0   0     0   0
  Johnny Williams p                   1   0   0    0     0   0     0   1
Totals                               26   4   7    2     3   5    27  16

FIELDING -
DP: 2.  Artie Wilson, Archie Ware, Piper Davis 2, Cowan Hyde. 
E: 1.  Cowan Hyde. 

BATTING -
2B:  Cowan Hyde. 
SH:  Archie Ware 2, Alex Radcliff. 
HBP:  Sam Jethroe. 
IW:  Quincy Trouppe. 
Team LOB:  5

BASERUNNING -
SB:  Artie Wilson, Sam Jethroe, Cowan Hyde. 
CS:  Sam Jethroe, Willie Grace 3. 

PITCHING

East All Stars(E)                    IP      H   R   ER  BB  SO  HR  BFP
Barney Brown                         3       2   0    0   1   3   0  11
Bill Byrd L                          1.1     4   4    3   2   0   0  11
Jonas Gaines                         2.2     0   0    0   0   1   0  8
Leon Day                             1       1   0    0   0   1   0  3
Totals                               8       7   4    3   3   5   0  33

HBP:  Barney Brown. 
IW:  Bill Byrd. 

West All Stars(W)                    IP      H   R   ER  BB  SO  HR  BFP
Felix Evans                          3       1   0    0   0   2   0  10
Dan Bankhead W                       3       1   0    0   1   3   0  12
Johnny Williams SV                   3       2   1    1   1   0   0  11
Totals                               9       4   1    1   2   5   0  33

HBP:  Dan Bankhead, Johnny Williams. 


Data shown are Retrosheet's best estimates.
Data may be estimated, incomplete, or missing.

Umpires: HP - Virgil Blueitt, 1B - Fred McCreary, 2B - Bullet Rogan, 3B - Phil Cockrell

Time of Game: 2:24   Attendance: 45474

Retrosheet Play-by-Play Account
Game of Sunday, 8/18/1946 -- East All Stars(E) at West All
Stars(W) (D)

Starting Lineups:

   East                          West                          
1. H.Kimbro            cf        A.Wilson            ss        
2. L.Doby              2b        A.Ware              1b        
3. H.Easterling        3b        S.Jethroe           cf        
4. B.Leonard           1b        P.Davis             2b        
5. M.Irvin             lf        W.Grace             rf        
6. J.Gibson            c         A.Radcliff          3b        
7. G.Benson            rf        C.Hyde              lf        
8. S.Garcia            ss        Q.Trouppe           c         
9. B.Brown             p         F.Evans             p         

ALL STARS(E) 1ST: H.Kimbro grounded out (P.Davis to A.Ware);
L.Doby struck out; H.Easterling struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(W) 1ST: A.Wilson was called out on strikes; A.Ware
popped to S.Garcia; S.Jethroe was hit by a pitch; S.Jethroe was
caught stealing second (J.Gibson to S.Garcia); 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(E) 2ND: B.Leonard singled to center field (S.Jethroe
to A.Wilson) [B.Leonard out at second]; M.Irvin reached on an
error by C.Hyde [M.Irvin to third]; J.Gibson reached on a
fielder's choice (A.Wilson to Q.Trouppe) [M.Irvin out at home];
G.Benson flied to S.Jethroe; 0 R, 1 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E)
0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(W) 2ND: P.Davis struck out; W.Grace singled to left
field; W.Grace was caught stealing second (J.Gibson to
S.Garcia); A.Radcliff struck out; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  All
Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(E) 3RD: S.Garcia popped to A.Wilson; B.Brown grounded
out (A.Wilson to A.Ware); H.Kimbro popped to A.Wilson; 0 R, 0 H,
0 E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(W) 3RD: C.Hyde doubled to left-center; Q.Trouppe
walked; On a bunt F.Evans popped to B.Brown; A.Wilson lined to
G.Benson; A.Ware grounded out (L.Doby to B.Leonard); 0 R, 1 H, 0
E, 2 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(E) 4TH: D.BANKHEAD REPLACED F.EVANS (PITCHING);
L.Doby walked; H.Easterling forced L.Doby (A.Wilson to P.Davis)
[H.Easterling to first]; B.Leonard flied to S.Jethroe; M.Irvin
struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W)
0.

ALL STARS(W) 4TH: B.BYRD REPLACED B.BROWN (PITCHING); S.Jethroe
popped to S.Garcia; P.Davis walked; W.Grace singled to right
field [P.Davis scored (no RBI) (error by G.Benson), W.Grace to
second]; A.Radcliff out on a sacrifice bunt (B.Byrd to
B.Leonard) [W.Grace to third]; C.Hyde singled to center field
[W.Grace scored]; C.Hyde stole second; Q.Trouppe was walked
intentionally; D.Bankhead lined to L.Doby; 2 R, 2 H, 1 E, 2 LOB.
 All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(E) 5TH: J.Gibson struck out; G.Benson popped to
Q.Trouppe; S.Garcia was hit by a pitch; B.Byrd was called out on
strikes; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(W) 5TH: A.Wilson singled to shortstop; A.Ware out on
a sacrifice bunt (B.Byrd to B.Leonard) [A.Wilson to second];
S.Jethroe reached on an error by S.Garcia [A.Wilson to third,
S.Jethroe to first]; A.Wilson stole home and S.Jethroe stole
second; P.Davis singled to center field [S.Jethroe scored
(unearned)]; J.GAINES REPLACED B.BYRD (PITCHING); W.Grace forced
P.Davis (L.Doby to S.Garcia) [W.Grace to first]; W.Grace was
caught stealing second (J.Gibson to L.Doby); 1 R (0 ER), 2 H, 1
E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(E) 6TH: H.Kimbro flied to S.Jethroe; L.Doby singled
to center field; H.Easterling grounded out (P.Davis to A.Ware)
[L.Doby to second]; B.Leonard grounded out (P.Davis to A.Ware);
0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(W) 6TH: A.Radcliff was called out on strikes; C.Hyde
grounded out (B.Leonard to J.Gaines); Q.Trouppe flied to
H.Kimbro; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(E) 7TH: J.WILLIAMS REPLACED D.BANKHEAD (PITCHING);
M.Irvin grounded out (P.Davis to A.Ware); J.Gibson walked;
G.Benson grounded into a double play (P.Davis to A.Wilson to
A.Ware) [J.Gibson out at second]; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  All
Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(W) 7TH: J.Williams grounded out (L.Doby to
B.Leonard); A.Wilson reached on an error by S.Garcia [A.Wilson
to first]; A.Ware out on a sacrifice bunt (J.Gaines to
B.Leonard) [A.Wilson to second]; S.Jethroe flied to H.Kimbro; 0
R, 0 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(E) 8TH: M.WATKINS BATTED FOR S.GARCIA; M.Watkins was
hit by a pitch; P.SCANTLEBURY BATTED FOR J.GAINES; P.Scantlebury
singled to center field [M.Watkins to third]; T.BUTTS RAN FOR
P.SCANTLEBURY; H.Kimbro forced T.Butts (P.Davis to A.Wilson)
[H.Kimbro to first]; L.Doby hit into a double play (C.Hyde to
P.Davis) [M.Watkins scored, H.Kimbro out at second]; 1 R, 1 H, 0
E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E) 1, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(W) 8TH: L.DAY REPLACED M.WATKINS (PITCHING); T.BUTTS
STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING SS); P.Davis popped to L.Doby; W.Grace
singled to shortstop; A.Radcliff struck out; W.Grace was caught
stealing second (J.Gibson to T.Butts); 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB. 
All Stars(E) 1, All Stars(W) 4.

ALL STARS(E) 9TH: H.Easterling grounded out (P.Davis to
A.Ware); B.Leonard lined to W.Grace; M.Irvin singled to right
field; J.Gibson grounded out (J.Williams to A.Ware); 0 R, 1 H, 0
E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 1, All Stars(W) 4.

Final Totals      R   H   E  LOB
 All Stars(E)     1   4   3   5
 All Stars(W)     4   7   1   5


Back to Main Page for 1946 Negro League Season

Back to Main Page for Negro League Baseball

Data are shown for games which have been identified by Retrosheet. Missing data are not shown. Negro Leagues data should be viewed as incomplete.


Retrosheet website last updated April 28, 2024.
All data contained at this site is copyright 1996-2023 by Retrosheet. All Rights Reserved. Click here for information about the use of Retrosheet data

Send comments and suggestions to Tom Thress: tthress-ATsign-retrosheet.org.
Join the Retrosheet Discussion group here: RetroList
Retrosheet is an all-volunteer organization and a 501(c)(3) charitable organization. To volunteer, please e-mail Tom Thress. To make a donation, you can visit here: Donation Page