1889 Ohio: Cincinnati Red Stockings (AA), 3; Cleveland Spiders (NL), 2

Game 1, October 17, 1889
CLE  010 101 010   4 11  1
CIN  000 000 000   0  2  3
WP: Beatin, LP: Viau


Game 2, October 18, 1889
CIN  001 003 310   8 13  6
CLE  001 001 300   5 12  6
HR: Earle
WP: Mullane, LP: Bakely


Game 3, October 19, 1889
CLE  000 000 04   4  7  1
CIN  000 000 01   1  6  0
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Beatin, LP: Duryea


Game 4, October 24, 1889
CIN  020 200 102   7 14  1
CLE  100 000 001   2  3  2
WP: Duryea, LP: O'Brien


Game 5, October 26, 1889
CIN  002 100 000   3 12  0
CLE  001 000 000   1  4  4
WP: Mullane, LP: Beatin