1886 New York: Giants (NL), 3; Metropolitan (AA), 1

Game 1, October 16, 1886
NYA  100 00   1  5  4
NYN  101 02   4  4  4
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Keefe, LP: Schaffer


Game 2, October 17, 1886
NYA  200 001 000   3  8  2
NYN  300 000 11x   5  9  3
WP: Welch, LP: Lynch

Game 3, October 19, 1886
NYN  021 00   3  5  0
NYA  000 00   0  4  3
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Welch, LP: Cushman

Lansche book does not show the fourth game won by the Mets