1884 New York: Metropolitan (AA), 1; Gothams (NL), 1; one tie

Game 1, October 16, 1884
NYN  040 01   5  5  3
NYA  400 10   5  5  3
Game ended due to darkness


Game 2, October 17, 1884
NYN  102 302   8  8  2
NYA  402 021   9 10  6
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Becannon, LP: Begley

Game 3, October 18, 1884
NYN  122 13   9  7  3
NYA  112 03   7  7 11
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Keefe, LP: Welch