Expanded Replay Usage
Compiled by David Vincent
This list shows all instances of the use of the expanded replay system.
On January 16, 2014, the owners unanimously approved an expanded use of the replay
system to start in the 2014 season. This expansion covered the following play types:
� Book rule double (often incorrectly called �ground rule double�)
� Fair/foul (outfield only)
� Fan interference
� Force play (except fielder's touching of second base on a double play)
� Grounds rule
� Hit by pitch
� Home plate collision
� Passing runners on the base path
� Plate collisions [new rule in 2014]
� Record keeping (such as ball/strike counts)
� Runners touching a base (appeal play)
� Stadium boundary calls (such as a fielder falling into the fan area to make a catch)
� Tag play
� Timing play (run scoring before the third out)
� Trap play (outfield only)
The following play types were not covered in the new version of the system:
� Balls and strikes
� Checked swings
� Fair/foul (infield only)
� Interference
� Obstruction
� Trap play (infield only)
There were three outcomes defined:
� Confirmed � clear and convincing evidence that the call on the field was correct
� Stands � no clear and convincing evidence to confirm or overturn the call
� Overturned � clear and convincing evidence that the call on the field was incorrect
Reviews March 31 - April 30, 2014
Date Tm Opp In Initiator Umpire Type Ruling Time
03/31/2014 ATL MIL 6 Mgr Fredi Gonzalez Greg Gibson Force play Overturned 1:05
03/31/2014 WAS NYN 10 Mgr Matt Williams Clint Fagan Force play Confirmed 1:44
03/31/2014 CLE OAK 6 Ump Mike Winters Mike Winters HP collision Confirmed 1:06
03/31/2014 CHN PIT 5 Mgr Rich Renteria Bob Davidson Force play Confirmed 1:39
03/31/2014 PIT CHN 10 Mgr Clint Hurdle Bob Davidson Tag play Overturned 1:46
04/01/2014 SFN ARI 4 Mgr Bruce Bochy Chris Guccione Tag play Stands 3:19
04/01/2014 TOR TBA 7 Ump Brian Gorman Jim Wolf Home run Stands 3:36
04/01/2014 TOR TBA 9 Mgr John Gibbons Jim Wolf Force play Confirmed 1:20
04/01/2014 TEX PHI 6 Mgr Ron Washington Cory Blaser Tag play Overturned 2:18
04/02/2014 MIN CHA 7 Mgr Ron Gardenhire Dale Scott Other Overturned 4:40
04/02/2014 DET KCA 6 Mgr Brad Ausmus Chris Conroy Force play Overturned 2:45
04/02/2014 DET KCA 10 Mgr Brad Ausmus Chris Conroy Force play Overturned 1:11
04/02/2014 MIA COL 4 Mgr Mike Redmond Jerry Layne Force play Stands 2:50
04/02/2014 OAK CLE 2 Mgr Bob Melvin Mark Wegner Tag play Stands 4:45
04/02/2014 CLE OAK 6 Mgr Terry Francona Gabe Morales Tag play Overturned 1:22
04/02/2014 CHN PIT 8 Mgr Rich Renteria John Tumpane Force play Overturned 2:27
04/02/2014 PIT CHN 8 Mgr Clint Hurdle Bob Davidson Hit by pitch Stands 4:35
04/02/2014 CHN PIT 13 Mgr Rich Renteria John Hirschbeck Force play Stands 1:47
04/03/2014 SLN CIN 7 Ump Gary Cederstrom Mark Ripperger Home run Confirmed 2:08
04/03/2014 NYA HOU 9 Ump Gerry Davis Brian Knight Record keeping Rcd keeping 2:20
04/03/2014 COL MIA 3 Mgr Walt Weiss Jerry Layne Force play Stands 2:35
04/03/2014 MIA COL 8 Ump Jerry Layne Hunter Wendelstedt Tag play Confirmed 1:25
04/03/2014 OAK SEA 5 Ump Fieldin Culbreth Sean Barber HP collision Confirmed 4:15
04/03/2014 OAK SEA 12 Ump Fieldin Culbreth Fieldin Culbreth Home run Confirmed 0:45
04/04/2014 DET BAL 5 Mgr Brad Ausmus Kerwin Danley Force play Confirmed 1:30
04/04/2014 KCA CHA 7 Mgr Ned Yost Ted Barrett Force play Stands 2:49
04/04/2014 SFN LAN 7 Mgr Bruce Bochy Marty Foster Tag play Overturned 1:16
04/04/2014 TBA TEX 7 Mgr Joe Maddon Hunter Wendelstedt Trap play (outfield) Overturned 1:45
04/04/2014 NYA TOR 3 Mgr Joe Girardi Dana DeMuth Force play Overturned 1:20
04/04/2014 NYA TOR 8 Mgr Joe Girardi Dana DeMuth Force play Confirmed 1:20
04/04/2014 ATL WAS 5 Mgr Fredi Gonzalez Marvin Hudson Boundary call Overturned 2:50
04/05/2014 LAN SFN 7 Mgr Don Mattingly Joe West Tag play Stands 1:40
04/05/2014 NYN CIN 9 Mgr Terry Collins James Hoye Force play Overturned 2:17
04/05/2014 TBA TEX 2 Mgr Joe Maddon Mike DiMuro Force play Overturned 1:35
04/05/2014 NYA TOR 3 Ump Dana DeMuth Dana DeMuth HP collision Confirmed 1:47
04/06/2014 BOS MIL 2 Mgr John Farrell Tim Timmons Force play Confirmed 1:40
04/06/2014 PHI CHN 5 Mgr Ryne Sandberg CB Bucknor Force play Stands 2:00
04/06/2014 CLE MIN 9 Mgr Terry Francona Jerry Meals Tag play Confirmed 1:22
04/06/2014 COL ARI 1 Mgr Walt Weiss Mike Muchlinski Force play Overturned 2:14
04/06/2014 KCA CHA 6 Mgr Ned Yost Paul Schrieber Force play Overturned 1:08
04/06/2014 CHA KCA 6 Mgr Robin Ventura Paul Schrieber Force play Stands 1:47
04/06/2014 OAK SEA 4 Mgr Bob Melvin Jim Reynolds Tag play Confirmed 2:00
04/06/2014 TOR NYA 6 Mgr John Gibbons Lance Barrett Tag play Stands 2:20
04/06/2014 WAS ATL 1 Mgr Matt Williams Marvin Hudson Force play Stands 1:35
04/07/2014 TEX BOS 1 Mgr Ron Washington Jordan Baker Force play Stands 1:50
04/07/2014 TBA KCA 8 Mgr Joe Maddon Quinn Wolcott Force play Confirmed 1:05
04/07/2014 OAK MIN 3 Ump Bill Miller Vic Carapazza Home run Stands 4:10
04/08/2014 NYN ATL 8 Mgr Terry Collins Mark Ripperger Force play Overturned 3:18
04/08/2014 TBA KCA 3 Mgr Joe Maddon Phil Cuzzi Force play Confirmed 0:52
04/08/2014 DET LAN 9 Mgr Brad Ausmus Chris Guccione Tag play Confirmed 0:55
04/08/2014 SEA ANA 5 Mgr Lloyd McClendon Seth Buckminster Other Overturned 2:51
04/08/2014 HOU TOR 8 Ump Jerry Layne Mike Estabrook HP collision Confirmed 1:32
04/09/2014 BOS TEX 8 Ump Jerry Meals Jerry Meals Home run Confirmed 0:39
04/09/2014 CHN PIT 6 Mgr Rich Renteria Mark Carlson Force play Overturned 1:21
04/09/2014 PIT CHN 9 Ump Jeff Nelson Scott Barry Home run Confirmed 0:33
04/09/2014 CLE SDN 1 Mgr Terry Francona Bob Davidson Other Stands 1:57
04/09/2014 KCA TBA 2 Mgr Ned Yost Quinn Wolcott Tag play Stands 2:18
04/09/2014 OAK MIN 9 Mgr Bob Melvin Greg Gibson Force play Stands 2:25
04/09/2014 MIN OAK 9 Ump Bill Miller Vic Carapazza HP collision Confirmed 0:52
04/09/2014 MIL PHI 1 Mgr Ron Roenicke Adrian Johnson Force play Overturned 1:24
04/09/2014 SEA ANA 9 Mgr Lloyd McClendon Seth Buckminster Tag play Confirmed 1:08
04/09/2014 MIA WAS 2 Ump Jeff Kellogg Toby Basner Home run Overturned 1:34
04/09/2014 WAS MIA 4 Ump Jeff Kellogg D.J. Reyburn Home run Stands 1:03
04/09/2014 MIA WAS 8 Ump Jeff Kellogg Dan Bellino HP collision Confirmed 0:44
04/10/2014 OAK MIN 6 Ump Bill Miller Adam Hamari HP collision Confirmed 0:46
04/10/2014 ARI SFN 1 Mgr Kirk Gibson Jim Reynolds Tag play Stands 2:25
04/10/2014 TOR HOU 5 Mgr John Gibbons Gabe Morales Force play Confirmed 1:17
04/11/2014 WAS ATL 7 Ump Larry Vanover Adrian Johnson HP collision Confirmed 1:56
04/11/2014 CIN TBA 9 Mgr Bryan Price D.J. Reyburn Hit by pitch Confirmed 1:23
04/11/2014 SEA OAK 4 Ump Tom Hallion Pat Hoberg Home run Overturned 1:43
04/11/2014 CHN SLN 9 Mgr Rich Renteria Gabe Morales Hit by pitch Stands 2:15
04/12/2014 WAS ATL 3 Mgr Matt Williams Angel Hernandez Force play Stands 3:43
04/12/2014 TOR BAL 4 Mgr John Gibbons Chris Conroy Force play Stands 2:38
04/12/2014 CLE CHA 1 Mgr Terry Francona Gerry Davis Tag play Overturned 1:49
04/12/2014 PIT MIL 9 Mgr Clint Hurdle Vic Carapazza Force play Confirmed 0:41
04/12/2014 BOS NYA 8 Mgr John Farrell Ron Kulpa Tag play Confirmed 1:00 (1)
04/12/2014 PHI MIA 2 Mgr Ryne Sandberg Mark Ripperger Force play Overturned 2:10
04/12/2014 SDN DET 8 Mgr Buddy Black Mike Winters Tag play Overturned 0:44
04/12/2014 CHN SLN 3 Mgr Rich Renteria Jerry Layne Force play Overturned 1:28
04/13/2014 CHA CLE 2 Ump Gerry Davis Brian Knight Home run Confirmed 1:00
04/13/2014 TBA CIN 7 Mgr Joe Maddon Jim Reynolds Force play Confirmed 0:50
04/13/2014 NYA BOS 4 Mgr Joe Girardi Bob Davidson Force play Overturned 3:00 (3)
04/13/2014 PHI MIA 6 Ump Gary Cederstrom Mark Ripperger HP collision Confirmed 0:54 (1)
04/13/2014 HOU TEX 1 Mgr Bo Porter Joe West Force play Overturned 0:44
04/14/2014 ANA OAK 9 Mgr Mike Scioscia Chris Segal Force play Stands 3:15
04/14/2014 TBA BAL 5 Mgr Joe Maddon Greg Gibson Force play Stands 2:47
04/14/2014 CIN PIT 4 Mgr Bryan Price Brian Knight Fair/foul (outfield) Overturned 2:30
04/14/2014 WAS MIA 1 Ump Joe West Clint Fagan Home run Confirmed 1:29
04/14/2014 SEA TEX 6 Mgr Lloyd McClendon Paul Schrieber Force play Overturned 3:30 (3)
04/15/2014 ARI NYN 5 Mgr Kirk Gibson Mike DiMuro Force play Overturned 1:48
04/15/2014 CHA BOS 2 Mgr Robin Ventura Cory Blaser Force play Stands 2:23
04/15/2014 PIT CIN 8 Mgr Clint Hurdle Quinn Wolcott Force play Overturned 1:23
04/15/2014 SFN LAN 10 Mgr Bruce Bochy Andy Fletcher Force play Overturned 1:24
04/16/2014 OAK ANA 7 Mgr Bob Melvin Tim Timmons Hit by pitch Stands 3:10
04/16/2014 PIT CIN 5 Mgr Clint Hurdle Gerry Davis Force play Overturned 0:44
04/16/2014 CIN PIT 8 Ump Gerry Davis Quinn Wolcott HP collision Confirmed 1:10
04/16/2014 CLE DET 8 Mgr Terry Francona Lance Barrett Force play Stands 1:28
04/16/2014 HOU KCA 9 Mgr Bo Porter CB Bucknor Force play Overturned 2:54
04/16/2014 WAS MIA 6 Ump Joe West Rob Drake Home run Confirmed 1:13
04/16/2014 CHN NYA 2 Mgr Rich Renteria Manny Gonzalez Force play Overturned 1:52
04/16/2014 CHN NYA 7 Mgr Rich Renteria Manny Gonzalez Force play Stands 2:46
04/16/2014 LAN SFN 2 Mgr Don Mattingly Seth Buckminster Tag play Stands 4:25
04/17/2014 KCA HOU 2 Mgr Ned Yost Tripp Gibson Force play Overturned 1:28
04/17/2014 PHI ATL 5 Mgr Ryne Sandberg Bill Welke Tag play Overturned 1:47
04/17/2014 PIT MIL 7 Mgr Clint Hurdle Jim Reynolds Tag play Stands 2:50
04/18/2014 BOS BAL 1 Mgr John Farrell Will Little Fair/foul (outfield) Stands 3:12
04/18/2014 BOS BAL 8 Ump Ted Barrett Mark Carlson Force play Overturned 1:16
04/18/2014 ANA DET 4 Ump Gerry Davis Phil Cuzzi Home run Overturned 1:59
04/18/2014 MIA SEA 9 Mgr Mike Redmond Lance Barrett Force play Overturned 1:48
04/18/2014 NYA TBA 2 Mgr Joe Girardi Marty Foster Force play Overturned 0:47
04/19/2014 BAL BOS 6 Mgr Buck Showalter Ted Barrett Force play Overturned 0:49
04/19/2014 COL PHI 3 Ump Tim Welke Tim Welke HP collision Overturned 1:44
04/19/2014 DET ANA 3 Mgr Brad Ausmus Gerry Davis Tag play Overturned 1:15
04/19/2014 ANA DET 4 Mgr Mike Scioscia Quinn Wolcott Tag play Overturned 1:52
04/19/2014 HOU OAK 8 Ump Mike Winters Mike Winters Record keeping Rcd keeping 1:28
04/20/2014 BOS BAL 9 Ump Ted Barrett Paul Schrieber Home run Stands 2:02
04/20/2014 CIN CHN 3 Mgr Bryan Price Doug Eddings Tag play Overturned 1:40
04/20/2014 PHI COL 6 Mgr Ryne Sandberg Todd Tichenor Tag play Overturned 1:25
04/20/2014 COL PHI 9 Mgr Walt Weiss Tim Timmons Force play Overturned 1:10
04/20/2014 COL PHI 9 Mgr Walt Weiss Tim Timmons Force play Confirmed 0:32
04/20/2014 ANA DET 8 Mgr Mike Scioscia Quinn Wolcott Tag play Stands 3:15
04/20/2014 MIA SEA 8 Mgr Mike Redmond Ed Hickox Force play Overturned 2:20
04/20/2014 NYN ATL 10 Mgr Terry Collins Tom Hallion Grounds rule Confirmed 0:47
04/20/2014 MIL PIT 8 Mgr Ron Roenicke Manny Gonzalez Force play Confirmed 0:45
04/20/2014 SFN SDN 3 Mgr Bruce Bochy Mike DiMuro Tag play Overturned 1:29
04/20/2014 NYA TBA 4 Mgr Joe Girardi Rob Drake Other Overturned 1:47
04/20/2014 TBA NYA 11 Mgr Joe Maddon Joe West Tag play Overturned 2:05
04/20/2014 CHA TEX 6 Mgr Robin Ventura James Hoye Hit by pitch Stands 3:11
04/21/2014 MIA ATL 8 Mgr Mike Redmond Marvin Hudson Force play Overturned 3:40
04/21/2014 CHA DET 4 Mgr Robin Ventura Tripp Gibson Force play Stands 2:30
04/21/2014 DET CHA 7 Mgr Brad Ausmus Tripp Gibson Fair/foul (outfield) Stands 1:53
04/21/2014 CHA DET 7 Ump Dan Iassogna CB Bucknor Tag play Overturned 2:36
04/21/2014 OAK TEX 7 Mgr Bob Melvin Adrian Johnson Force play Overturned 3:43
04/21/2014 CIN PIT 8 Mgr Bryan Price Gary Cederstrom Tag play Confirmed 2:21
04/21/2014 SEA HOU 7 Ump Jeff Nelson Marcus Pattillo Home run Confirmed 1:19
04/21/2014 SEA HOU 8 Mgr Lloyd McClendon Jeff Nelson Force play Confirmed 1:30
04/21/2014 ANA WAS 3 Mgr Mike Scioscia Jerry Meals Force play Overturned 1:15
04/22/2014 PIT CIN 7 Mgr Clint Hurdle Mark Ripperger Tag play Overturned 2:08
04/22/2014 TBA MIN 5 Ump Ted Barrett Paul Schrieber Record keeping Rcd keeping 1:56 (2)
04/22/2014 WAS ANA 8 Mgr Matt Williams Jordan Baker Tag play Stands 2:12
04/23/2014 CHN ARI 9 Mgr Rich Renteria D.J. Reyburn Force play Confirmed 1:28
04/23/2014 SLN NYN 9 Mgr Mike Matheny Marty Foster Tag play Confirmed 1:47
04/23/2014 OAK TEX 1 Mgr Bob Melvin Larry Vanover Tag play Overturned 2:12
04/24/2014 NYA BOS 2 Mgr Joe Girardi Phil Cuzzi Hit by pitch Overturned 2:47
04/24/2014 ARI CHN 1 Mgr Kirk Gibson Dan Bellino Tag play Stands 4:05
04/24/2014 CLE KCA 1 Ump Bill Miller Greg Gibson HP collision Stands 3:00
04/24/2014 LAN PHI 5 Ump Hunter Wendelstedt Mike DiMuro HP collision Confirmed 3:18
04/24/2014 PHI LAN 6 Mgr Ryne Sandberg Hunter Wendelstedt Force play Stands 1:44
04/24/2014 TOR BAL 8 Mgr John Gibbons Mike Winters Hit by pitch Stands 1:56
04/24/2014 WAS SDN 9 Mgr Matt Williams Doug Eddings Tag play Overturned 1:24
04/25/2014 PHI ARI 7 Mgr Ryne Sandberg Bob Davidson Tag play Overturned 2:18
04/25/2014 CIN ATL 9 Mgr Bryan Price Vic Carapazza Force play Confirmed 2:07
04/25/2014 TBA CHA 9 Mgr Joe Maddon Tim Timmons Force play Confirmed 2:27
04/25/2014 OAK HOU 5 Mgr Bob Melvin Jerry Meals Fair/foul (outfield) Stands 2:00
04/25/2014 MIL CHN 3 Mgr Ron Roenicke Kerwin Danley Force play Overturned 2:20
04/25/2014 CHN MIL 8 Mgr Rich Renteria Kerwin Danley Force play Overturned 1:05
04/25/2014 PIT SLN 3 Mgr Clint Hurdle Ted Barrett Tag play Overturned 2:36
04/26/2014 PHI ARI 9 Mgr Ryne Sandberg Chris Conroy Tag play Overturned 3:37
04/26/2014 HOU OAK 2 Mgr Bo Porter Paul Emmel Force play Overturned 2:37
04/26/2014 LAN COL 3 Mgr Don Mattingly Stu Scheurwater Tag play Overturned 0:46
04/26/2014 LAN COL 8 Mgr Don Mattingly Paul Nauert Timing play Confirmed 1:03
04/26/2014 DET MIN 3 Mgr Brad Ausmus Brian O'Nora Tag play Overturned 1:28
04/26/2014 CHN MIL 9 Mgr Rich Renteria Lance Barksdale Force play Confirmed 0:44
04/26/2014 NYN MIA 9 Mgr Terry Collins Mike Muchlinski Force play Overturned 2:08
04/26/2014 SEA TEX 6 Mgr Lloyd McClendon Gabe Morales Force play Stands 2:56
04/26/2014 BOS TOR 2 Mgr John Farrell Marty Foster Force play Overturned 1:00
04/26/2014 WAS SDN 5 Mgr Matt Williams Cory Blaser Tag play Overturned 1:47
04/27/2014 CIN ATL 1 Mgr Bryan Price Greg Gibson Tag play Stands 1:56 (3)
04/27/2014 OAK HOU 9 Mgr Bob Melvin Paul Emmel Hit by pitch Overturned 1:15
04/27/2014 LAN COL 7 Mgr Don Mattingly Larry Vanover Force play Overturned 1:32
04/27/2014 NYA ANA 8 Mgr Joe Girardi Bill Welke Hit by pitch Overturned 2:55
04/27/2014 PIT SLN 6 Mgr Clint Hurdle Ted Barrett Force play Stands 2:57
04/28/2014 TBA CHA 7 Mgr Joe Maddon Tim Timmons Tag play Stands 2:48
04/28/2014 SFN SDN 3 Mgr Bruce Bochy Angel Hernandez Force play Overturned 1:31
04/28/2014 SDN SFN 4 Mgr Buddy Black Angel Hernandez Force play Overturned 1:26
04/28/2014 SLN MIL 6 Mgr Mike Matheny D.J. Reyburn Force play Stands 1:46
04/28/2014 TEX OAK 3 Mgr Ron Washington Marcus Pattillo Tag play Overturned 2:16
04/28/2014 TEX OAK 8 Mgr Ron Washington Marcus Pattillo Tag play Confirmed 1:39
04/28/2014 OAK TEX 8 Ump Jeff Nelson Jeff Nelson Force play Overturned 1:30
04/29/2014 ANA CLE 5 Mgr Mike Scioscia Gabe Morales Force play Overturned 1:47
04/29/2014 CLE ANA 8 Mgr Terry Francona Gabe Morales Force play Stands 1:26
04/29/2014 KCA TOR 2 Mgr Ned Yost Mark Wegner Force play Overturned 1:03
04/29/2014 TOR KCA 9 Ump Bob Davidson Mark Wegner Home run Stands 1:27
04/29/2014 SEA NYA 5 Mgr Lloyd McClendon Bill Miller Force play Overturned 0:38
04/29/2014 TEX OAK 5 Mgr Ron Washington Laz Diaz Fair/foul (outfield) Stands 1:43
04/30/2014 CHA DET 3 Mgr Robin Ventura Jerry Layne Force play Overturned 0:45
04/30/2014 CHN CIN 9 Mgr Rich Renteria Joe West Force play Stands 1:50
04/30/2014 KCA TOR 4 Ump Bob Davidson Mark Wegner HP collision Confirmed 2:25
04/30/2014 MIA ATL 5 Mgr Mike Redmond Jim Reynolds Tag play Overturned 1:28
04/30/2014 MIN LAN 3 Mgr Ron Gardenhire Chris Segal Tag play Stands 2:00
04/30/2014 SLN MIL 6 Ump Jeff Kellogg Toby Basner Home run Overturned 0:52
(1) - MLB later acknowledged that the call should have been overturned.
(2) - MLB later acknowledged that an incorrect call was made on a pitch.
(3) - This call resulted in an ejection.
See Replayed Homer Calls for additional information about and descriptions of the home run reviews.
Page Updated: 7/15/2014
All data contained at this site is copyright �
1996-2014