Read Me
Retrosheet Boxscore: West All Stars (ASW) 2, East All Stars (ASE) 10

Retrosheet


West All Stars (ASW) 2, East All Stars (ASE) 10

Game played on Sunday, August 23, 1936 at Comiskey Park, Chicago

      
Play-by-play deduced from newspaper game stories and box scores. Fielding credits from newspaper box scores.

ASE   2 0 0  1 3 0  2 2 0  -  10 15  2                              
ASW   0 0 0  0 0 1  0 1 0  -   2  9  3                              
                              
BATTING                              
                              
East All Stars                    AB   R   H   RBI      BB   SO      PO   A
Cool Papa Bell cf                 3    1    3    1       0    0       1    0
Wild Bill Wright ph, cf           3    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Sammy Hughes 2b                   5    2    1    0       1    0       3    4
Sam Bankhead lf                   5    1    2    0       0    0       2    0
Biz Mackey c                      2    0    2    2       0    0       1    1
Josh Gibson ph, c                 3    2    2    1       0    0       7    0
Jimmie Crutchfield rf             2    0    0    0       0    1       1    0
Zollie Wright ph, rf              1    2    1    2       2    0       0    0
Chester Williams ss               5    0    1    1       0    1       1    5
Jim West 1b                       2    1    1    0       1    0       9    0
Johnny Washington 1b              1    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Judy Johnson 3b                   3    0    1    1       0    0       1    1
Felton Snow ph, 3b                2    1    1    0       0    0       0    0
Leroy Matlock p                   1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Bill Byrd ph, p                   3    0    0    0       0    1       0    1
Satchel Paige p                   1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Totals                           42   10   15    8       4    3      27   12
                              
FIELDING -                              
E: Johnny Washington                               
PB: Josh Gibson                               
                              
BATTING -                              
2B: Cool Papa Bell, Sammy Hughes, Sam Bankhead                               
SH: Sam Bankhead, Judy Johnson                               
HBP: Jim West                               
GDP: Chester Williams                               
Team LOB: 10                              
                              
BASERUNNING -                              
SB: Cool Papa Bell, Josh Gibson                               
CS: Cool Papa Bell                               
                              
West All Stars                    AB   R   H   RBI      BB   SO      PO   A
Eddie Dwight cf                   2    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Henry Milton ph, cf               2    0    0    0       1    0       1    0
Newt Allen 2b, ss                 5    0    0    0       0    2       6    4
Wilson Redus rf                   1    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Lou Dials ph, rf                  3    0    0    0       0    1       2    0
Alex Radcliff 3b                  4    1    3    0       0    1       0    0
Bullet Rogan lf                   1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Herman Dunlap ph, lf              3    1    1    0       0    1       1    0
Harry Else c                      0    0    0    0       1    0       3    0
Subby Byas ph, c                  3    0    1    0       0    0       2    0
Willard Brown ss                  1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Pat Patterson ph, 2b              3    0    3    1       0    0       1    0
Curtis Harris 1b                  4    0    1    0       0    0      10    1
Willie Cornelius p                1    0    0    0       0    0       0    2
Floyd Kranson p                   0    0    0    0       0    0       0    2
Ben Taylor ph                     1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Andy Cooper p                     0    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Ted Trent p                       2    0    0    0       0    1       0    0
Totals                           36    2    9    1       2    6      27    9
                              
FIELDING -                              
DP: 1. Cornelius-Allen-Harris                              
E: Newt Allen, Lou Dials, Willard Brown                               
                              
BATTING -                              
Team LOB: 9                              
                              
                              
PITCHING                              
                              
East All Stars                    IP    H    R   ER   BB   SO   HR   BFP      
Leroy Matlock W                    3    2    0    0    1    0    0    11      
Bill Byrd                          3    5    1    1    1    2    0    15      
Satchel Paige                      3    2    1    0    0    4    0    12      
Totals                             9    9    2    1    2    6    0    38      
                              
                              
West All Stars                    IP    H    R   ER   BB   SO   HR   BFP      
Willie Cornelius L                 3    5    2    2    1    2    0    15      
Floyd Kranson                      2    5    4    4    1    1    0    12      
Andy Cooper                        1    1    0    0    0    0    0     4      
Ted Trent                          3    4    4    2    2    0    0    16      
Totals                             9   15   10    8    4    3    0    47      
                              
HBP: Floyd Kranson                               
                              
Time of Game: 2:28   Attendance: 26400                              
Retrosheet Play-by-Play Account
Game of Sunday, 8/23/1936 -- East East at West West (D)

Starting Lineups:

   East                          West                          
1. C.Bell              cf        E.Dwight            cf        
2. S.Hughes            2b        N.Allen             2b        
3. S.Bankhead          lf        W.Redus             rf        
4. B.Mackey            c         A.Radcliff          3b        
5. J.Crutchfield       rf        B.Rogan             lf        
6. C.Williams          ss        H.Else              c         
7. J.West              1b        W.Brown             ss        
8. J.Johnson           3b        C.Harris            1b        
9. L.Matlock           p         W.Cornelius         p         

EAST 1ST: C.Bell singled to right field; C.Bell stole second;
S.Hughes walked; S.Bankhead out on a sacrifice bunt (unknown
fielder) [C.Bell to third, S.Hughes to second]; B.Mackey singled
to center field [C.Bell scored, S.Hughes scored]; J.Crutchfield
struck out; C.Williams struck out; 2 R, 2 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  East
2, West 0.

WEST 1ST: E.Dwight grounded out (J.Johnson to J.West); N.Allen
grounded out (S.Hughes to J.West); W.Redus popped to J.West in
foul territory; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

EAST 2ND: J.West singled; J.Johnson out on unknown play;
L.Matlock out on unknown play; C.Bell singled [J.West to
second]; S.Hughes out on unknown play; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 2 LOB. 
East 2, West 0.

WEST 2ND: A.Radcliff singled; B.Rogan out on unknown play;
H.Else walked [A.Radcliff to second]; W.Brown out on unknown
play; C.Harris singled (unknown fielders) [A.Radcliff out at
home, H.Else to second]; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

EAST 3RD: S.Bankhead out on unknown play; B.Mackey singled;
J.Crutchfield reached on an error by W.Brown [B.Mackey to
second, J.Crutchfield to first]; C.Williams grounded into a
double play (W.Cornelius to N.Allen to C.Harris) [J.Crutchfield
out at second]; 0 R, 1 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

WEST 3RD: W.Cornelius grounded out (C.Williams to J.West);
E.Dwight out on unknown play; N.Allen out on unknown play; 0 R,
0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

EAST 4TH: F.KRANSON REPLACED W.CORNELIUS (PITCHING); J.West
walked; J.Johnson out on a sacrifice bunt (unknown fielder)
[J.West to second]; B.BYRD BATTED FOR L.MATLOCK; B.Byrd struck
out; C.Bell doubled [J.West scored]; C.Bell was caught stealing
third (unknown fielders); 1 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 3, West 0.

WEST 4TH: B.BYRD STAYED IN GAME (PITCHING); L.DIALS BATTED FOR
W.REDUS; L.Dials out on unknown play; A.Radcliff struck out;
H.DUNLAP BATTED FOR B.ROGAN; H.Dunlap out on unknown play; 0 R,
0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 3, West 0.

EAST 5TH: L.DIALS STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING RF); H.DUNLAP STAYED
IN GAME (PLAYING LF); S.Hughes doubled; S.Bankhead grounded out
(C.Harris unassisted); J.GIBSON BATTED FOR B.MACKEY; J.Gibson
singled to center field [S.Hughes to third]; J.Gibson stole
second; Z.WRIGHT BATTED FOR J.CRUTCHFIELD; Z.Wright singled
[S.Hughes scored, J.Gibson scored]; C.Williams out on unknown
play; J.West was hit by a pitch [Z.Wright to second]; J.Johnson
singled [Z.Wright scored, J.West to second]; B.Byrd out on
unknown play; 3 R, 4 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 6, West 0.

WEST 5TH: J.GIBSON STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING C); Z.WRIGHT STAYED
IN GAME (PLAYING RF); S.BYAS BATTED FOR H.ELSE; S.Byas singled;
P.PATTERSON BATTED FOR W.BROWN; P.Patterson singled [S.Byas to
second]; C.Harris out on unknown play; B.TAYLOR BATTED FOR
F.KRANSON; B.Taylor out on unknown play; H.MILTON BATTED FOR
E.DWIGHT; H.Milton walked [S.Byas to third, P.Patterson to
second]; N.Allen struck out; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 3 LOB.  East 6, West
0.

EAST 6TH: H.MILTON STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING CF); N.ALLEN CHANGED
POSITIONS (PLAYING SS); S.BYAS STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING C);
P.PATTERSON STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING 2B); A.COOPER REPLACED
B.TAYLOR (PITCHING); W.WRIGHT BATTED FOR C.BELL; W.Wright out on
unknown play; S.Hughes out on unknown play; S.Bankhead doubled;
J.Gibson out on unknown play; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  East 6,
West 0.

WEST 6TH: W.WRIGHT STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING CF); L.Dials out on
unknown play; A.Radcliff singled; H.Dunlap singled [A.Radcliff
to second]; S.Byas forced A.Radcliff (unknown fielders)
[H.Dunlap to second, S.Byas to first]; P.Patterson singled
[H.Dunlap scored, S.Byas to second]; C.Harris out on unknown
play; 1 R, 3 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 6, West 1.

EAST 7TH: T.TRENT REPLACED A.COOPER (PITCHING); Z.Wright
walked; C.Williams out on unknown play; J.West out on unknown
play; F.SNOW BATTED FOR J.JOHNSON; F.Snow singled [Z.Wright to
second]; B.Byrd reached on an error by L.Dials [Z.Wright scored
(unearned) (no RBI), F.Snow scored (unearned) (no RBI), B.Byrd
to first]; W.Wright out on unknown play; 2 R (0 ER), 1 H, 1 E, 1
LOB.  East 8, West 1.

WEST 7TH: F.SNOW STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING 3B); S.PAIGE REPLACED
B.BYRD (PITCHING); J.WASHINGTON REPLACED J.WEST (PLAYING 1B);
T.Trent struck out; H.Milton out on unknown play; N.Allen out on
unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 8, West 1.

EAST 8TH: S.Hughes out on unknown play; S.Bankhead singled to
shortstop [S.Bankhead to second (error by N.Allen)]; J.Gibson
singled [S.Bankhead scored]; Z.Wright walked [J.Gibson to
second]; C.Williams singled [J.Gibson scored, Z.Wright to
second]; J.Washington out on unknown play; F.Snow out on unknown
play; 2 R, 3 H, 1 E, 2 LOB.  East 10, West 1.

WEST 8TH: L.Dials struck out; A.Radcliff singled; H.Dunlap
struck out; J.Gibson allowed a passed ball [A.Radcliff to
second]; S.Byas reached on an error by J.Washington [A.Radcliff
scored (unearned) (no RBI), S.Byas to first]; P.Patterson
singled [S.Byas to second]; C.Harris out on unknown play; 1 R (0
ER), 2 H, 1 E, 2 LOB.  East 10, West 2.

EAST 9TH: S.Paige out on unknown play; W.Wright out on unknown
play; S.Hughes out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East
10, West 2.

WEST 9TH: T.Trent out on unknown play; H.Milton out on unknown
play; N.Allen struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 10, West 2.

Final Totals      R   H   E  LOB
 East            10  15   1  10
 West             2   9   3   9

Back to Main Page for Negro League All-Star Games
Back to Main Page for Negro League Baseball

Read Me