Read Me
Retrosheet Boxscore: East All Stars (ASE)10, West All Stars (ASW) 2

Retrosheet


East All Stars (ASE)10, West All Stars (ASW) 2

Game played on Sunday, August 23, 1936 at Comiskey Park I, Chicago, IL

                              
Play-by-play deduced from newspaper game stories and box scores. Fielding credits from newspaper box scores.

ASE  2 0 0  1 3 0  2 2 0   -  10 15  1                              
ASW  0 0 0  0 0 1  0 1 0   -   2  9  3                              
                              
BATTING                              
                              
East All Stars                    AB   R   H   RBI      BB   SO      PO   A
Cool Papa Bell cf                 3    1    3    1       0    0       1    0
Wild Bill Wright ph, cf           3    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Sammy Hughes 2b                   5    2    1    0       1    0       3    4
Sam Bankhead lf                   4    1    2    0       0    0       2    0
Biz Mackey c                      2    0    2    2       0    0       1    1
Josh Gibson ph, c                 3    2    2    1       0    0       7    0
Jimmie Crutchfield rf             2    0    0    0       0    1       1    0
Zollie Wright ph, rf              1    2    1    2       2    0       0    0
Chester Williams ss               5    0    1    1       0    1       1    5
Jim West 1b                       2    1    1    0       1    0       9    0
Johnny Washington 1b              1    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Judy Johnson 3b                   2    0    1    1       0    0       1    1
Felton Snow ph, 3b                2    1    1    0       0    0       0    0
Leroy Matlock p                   1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Bill Byrd ph, p                   3    0    0    0       0    1       0    1
Satchel Paige p                   1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Totals                           40   10   15    8       4    3      27   12
                              
FIELDING -                              
E: Johnny Washington                             
PB: Josh Gibson                             
                              
BATTING -                              
2B: Cool Papa Bell; Sammy Hughes; Sam Bankhead                             
SH: Sam Bankhead; Judy Johnson                             
HBP: Jim West                             
GDP: Chester Williams                             
Team LOB: 10                              
                              
BASERUNNING -                              
SB: Cool Papa Bell; Josh Gibson                             
CS: Cool Papa Bell                             
                              
West All Stars                    AB   R   H   RBI      BB   SO      PO   A
Eddie Dwight cf                   2    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Henry Milton ph, cf               2    0    0    0       1    0       1    0
Newt Allen 2b, ss                 5    0    0    0       0    2       6    4
Wilson Redus rf                   1    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Lou Dials ph, rf                  3    0    0    0       0    1       2    0
Alex Radcliff 3b                  4    1    3    0       0    1       0    0
Bullet Rogan lf                   1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Herman Dunlap ph, lf              3    1    1    0       0    1       1    0
Harry Else c                      0    0    0    0       1    0       3    0
Subby Byas ph, c                  3    0    1    0       0    0       2    0
Willard Brown ss                  1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Pat Patterson ph, 2b              3    0    3    1       0    0       1    0
Curtis Harris 1b                  4    0    1    0       0    0      10    1
Willie Cornelius p                1    0    0    0       0    0       0    2
Floyd Kranson p                   0    0    0    0       0    0       0    2
Ben Taylor ph                     1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Andy Cooper p                     0    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Ted Trent p                       2    0    0    0       0    1       0    0
Totals                           36    2    9    1       2    6      27    9
                              
FIELDING -                              
DP: 1. Cornelius-Allen-Harris
E: Newt Allen; Lou Dials; Willard Brown                             
                              
BATTING -                              
Team LOB: 9                              
                              
                              
PITCHING                              
                              
East All Stars                    IP    H    R   ER   BB   SO   HR   BFP      
Leroy Matlock W                    3    2    0    0    1    0    0    11      
Bill Byrd                          3    5    1    1    1    2    0    15      
Satchel Paige                      3    2    1    0    0    4    0    12      
Totals                             9    9    2    1    2    6    0    38      
                              
                              
West All Stars                    IP    H    R   ER   BB   SO   HR   BFP      
Willie Cornelius L                 3    5    2    2    1    2    0    15      
Floyd Kranson                      2    5    4    4    1    1    0    12      
Andy Cooper                        1    1    0    0    0    0    0     4      
Ted Trent                          3    4    4    2    2    0    0    16      
Totals                             9   15   10    8    4    3    0    47      
                              
HBP: Floyd Kranson                             
                              
Time of Game: 2:28   Attendance: 26400                              
                              
Retrosheet Play-by-Play Account
Game of Sunday, 8/23/1936 -- East All Stars at West All Stars (D)

Starting Lineups:

   East                          West                          
1. C.Bell              cf        E.Dwight            cf        
2. S.Hughes            2b        N.Allen             2b        
3. S.Bankhead          lf        W.Redus             rf        
4. B.Mackey            c         A.Radcliff          3b        
5. J.Crutchfield       rf        B.Rogan             lf        
6. C.Williams          ss        H.Else              c         
7. J.West              1b        W.Brown             ss        
8. J.Johnson           3b        C.Harris            1b        
9. L.Matlock           p         W.Cornelius         p         

EAST 1ST: C.Bell singled to right field; C.Bell stole second;
S.Hughes walked; S.Bankhead out on a sacrifice bunt (W.Redus
unassisted) [C.Bell to third, S.Hughes to second]; B.Mackey
singled to center field [C.Bell scored, S.Hughes scored];
J.Crutchfield struck out; C.Williams struck out; 2 R, 2 H, 0 E,
1 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

WEST 1ST: E.Dwight grounded out (J.Johnson to J.West); N.Allen
grounded out (S.Hughes to J.West); W.Redus popped to J.West in
foul territory; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

EAST 2ND: J.West singled; J.Johnson out on unknown play;
L.Matlock out on unknown play; C.Bell singled [J.West to
second]; S.Hughes out on unknown play; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 2 LOB. 
East 2, West 0.

WEST 2ND: A.Radcliff singled; B.Rogan out on unknown play;
H.Else walked [A.Radcliff to second]; W.Brown out on unknown
play; C.Harris singled (J.Crutchfield unassisted) [A.Radcliff
out at home, H.Else to second]; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 2,
West 0.

EAST 3RD: S.Bankhead out on unknown play; B.Mackey singled;
J.Crutchfield reached on an error by W.Brown [B.Mackey to
second, J.Crutchfield to first]; C.Williams grounded into a
double play (W.Cornelius to N.Allen to C.Harris) [J.Crutchfield
out at second]; 0 R, 1 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

WEST 3RD: W.Cornelius grounded out (C.Williams to J.West);
E.Dwight out on unknown play; N.Allen out on unknown play; 0 R,
0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 2, West 0.

EAST 4TH: F.KRANSON REPLACED W.CORNELIUS (PITCHING); J.West
walked; J.Johnson out on a sacrifice bunt (W.Redus unassisted)
[J.West to second]; B.BYRD BATTED FOR L.MATLOCK; B.Byrd struck
out; C.Bell doubled [J.West scored]; C.Bell was caught stealing
third (W.Redus unassisted); 1 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 3, West
0.

WEST 4TH: B.BYRD STAYED IN GAME (PITCHING); L.DIALS BATTED FOR
W.REDUS; L.Dials out on unknown play; A.Radcliff struck out;
H.DUNLAP BATTED FOR B.ROGAN; H.Dunlap out on unknown play; 0 R,
0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 3, West 0.

EAST 5TH: L.DIALS STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING RF); H.DUNLAP STAYED
IN GAME (PLAYING LF); S.Hughes doubled; S.Bankhead grounded out
(C.Harris unassisted); J.GIBSON BATTED FOR B.MACKEY; J.Gibson
singled to center field [S.Hughes to third]; J.Gibson stole
second; Z.WRIGHT BATTED FOR J.CRUTCHFIELD; Z.Wright singled
[S.Hughes scored, J.Gibson scored]; C.Williams out on unknown
play; J.West was hit by a pitch [Z.Wright to second]; J.Johnson
singled [Z.Wright scored, J.West to second]; B.Byrd out on
unknown play; 3 R, 4 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 6, West 0.

WEST 5TH: J.GIBSON STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING C); Z.WRIGHT STAYED
IN GAME (PLAYING RF); S.BYAS BATTED FOR H.ELSE; S.Byas singled;
P.PATTERSON BATTED FOR W.BROWN; P.Patterson singled [S.Byas to
second]; C.Harris out on unknown play; B.TAYLOR BATTED FOR
F.KRANSON; B.Taylor out on unknown play; H.MILTON BATTED FOR
E.DWIGHT; H.Milton walked [S.Byas to third, P.Patterson to
second]; N.Allen struck out; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 3 LOB.  East 6, West
0.

EAST 6TH: H.MILTON STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING CF); N.ALLEN CHANGED
POSITIONS (PLAYING SS); S.BYAS STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING C);
P.PATTERSON STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING 2B); A.COOPER REPLACED
B.TAYLOR (PITCHING); W.WRIGHT BATTED FOR C.BELL; W.Wright out on
unknown play; S.Hughes out on unknown play; S.Bankhead doubled;
J.Gibson out on unknown play; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  East 6,
West 0.

WEST 6TH: W.WRIGHT STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING CF); L.Dials out on
unknown play; A.Radcliff singled; H.Dunlap singled [A.Radcliff
to second]; S.Byas forced A.Radcliff (Z.Wright unassisted)
[H.Dunlap to second, S.Byas to first]; P.Patterson singled
[H.Dunlap scored, S.Byas to second]; C.Harris out on unknown
play; 1 R, 3 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 6, West 1.

EAST 7TH: T.TRENT REPLACED A.COOPER (PITCHING); Z.Wright
walked; C.Williams out on unknown play; J.West out on unknown
play; F.SNOW BATTED FOR J.JOHNSON; F.Snow singled [Z.Wright to
second]; B.Byrd reached on an error by L.Dials [Z.Wright scored
(unearned) (no RBI), F.Snow scored (unearned) (no RBI), B.Byrd
to first]; W.Wright out on unknown play; 2 R (0 ER), 1 H, 1 E, 1
LOB.  East 8, West 1.

WEST 7TH: F.SNOW STAYED IN GAME (PLAYING 3B); S.PAIGE REPLACED
B.BYRD (PITCHING); J.WASHINGTON REPLACED J.WEST (PLAYING 1B);
T.Trent struck out; H.Milton out on unknown play; N.Allen out on
unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 8, West 1.

EAST 8TH: S.Hughes out on unknown play; S.Bankhead singled to
shortstop [S.Bankhead to second (error by N.Allen)]; J.Gibson
singled [S.Bankhead scored]; Z.Wright walked [J.Gibson to
second]; C.Williams singled [J.Gibson scored, Z.Wright to
second]; J.Washington out on unknown play; F.Snow out on unknown
play; 2 R, 3 H, 1 E, 2 LOB.  East 10, West 1.

WEST 8TH: L.Dials struck out; A.Radcliff singled; H.Dunlap
struck out; J.Gibson allowed a passed ball [A.Radcliff to
second]; S.Byas reached on an error by J.Washington [A.Radcliff
scored (unearned) (no RBI), S.Byas to first]; P.Patterson
singled [S.Byas to second]; C.Harris out on unknown play; 1 R (0
ER), 2 H, 1 E, 2 LOB.  East 10, West 2.

EAST 9TH: S.Paige out on unknown play; W.Wright out on unknown
play; S.Hughes out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East
10, West 2.

WEST 9TH: T.Trent out on unknown play; H.Milton out on unknown
play; N.Allen struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 10, West 2.

Final Totals      R   H   E  LOB
 East            10  15   1  10
 West             2   9   3   9
                              

Back to Main Page for Negro League All-Star Games
Back to Main Page for Negro League Baseball

Read Me