Read Me
Retrosheet Boxscore: West All Stars (ASW) 4, East All Stars (ASE) 1

Retrosheet


West All Stars (ASW) 4, East All Stars (ASE) 1

SABR Article

Game played on Sunday, August 18, 1946 at Comiskey Park, Chicago

                              
Play-by-play deduced from newspaper game stories and box scores. Fielding credits from newspaper box scores.

ASE   0 0 0  0 0 0  0 1 0  -   1  4  3        
ASW   0 0 0  2 2 0  0 0 x  -   4  7  1        
                              
BATTING                              
                              
East All Stars                    AB   R   H   RBI      BB   SO      PO   A
Henry Kimbro cf                   4    0    0    0       0    0       2    0
Larry Doby 2b                     3    0    1    1       1    1       3    3
Howard Easterling 3b              4    0    0    0       0    1       0    0
Buck Leonard 1b                   4    0    1    0       0    0       5    1
Monte Irvin lf                    4    0    1    0       0    1       0    0
Josh Gibson c                     3    0    0    0       1    1       5    4
Gene Benson rf                    3    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Silvio Garcia ss                  1    0    0    0       0    0       5    0
Murray Watkins ph                 0    1    0    0       0    0       0    0
Leon Day p                        0    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Barney Brown p                    1    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Bill Byrd p                       1    0    0    0       0    1       0    2
Jonas Gaines p                    0    0    0    0       0    0       1    1
Patricio Scantlebury ph           1    0    1    0       0    0       0    0
Tommy Butts pr, ss                0    0    0    0       0    0       1    0
Totals                           29    1    4    1       2    5      24   11
                              
FIELDING -                              
E: Gene Benson, Silvio Garcia (2)                               
                              
BATTING -                              
HBP: Silvio Garcia, Murray Watkins                               
GDP: Gene Benson                               
Team LOB: 5                              
                              
                              
West All Stars                    AB   R   H   RBI      BB   SO      PO   A
Artie Wilson ss                   4    1    1    0       0    1       5    4
Archie Ware 1b                    4    0    0    0       0    0       8    0
Sam Jethroe cf                    3    1    0    0       0    0       4    1
Piper Davis 2b                    3    1    1    1       1    1       2    5
Willie Grace rf                   4    1    3    1       0    0       1    0
Alex Radcliff 3b                  4    0    0    0       0    3       0    1
Cowan Hyde lf                     3    0    2    1       0    0       0    1
Quincy Trouppe c                  1    0    0    0       2    0       7    0
Felix Evans p                     1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Dan Bankhead p                    1    0    0    0       0    0       0    0
Johnny Williams p                 1    0    0    0       0    0       0    1
Totals                           29    4    7    3       3    5      27   13
                              
FIELDING -                              
DP: 2. Davis-Wilson-Ware; Hyde-Davis                              
E: Cowan Hyde                               
                              
BATTING -                              
2B: Cowan Hyde                               
SH: Archie Ware (2), Alex Radcliff                               
HBP: Sam Jethroe                               
IBB: Quincy Trouppe                               
Team LOB: 5                              
                              
BASERUNNING -                              
SB: Artie Wilson, Sam Jethroe, Cowan Hyde                               
CS: Sam Jethroe, Willie Grace (3)                               
                              
PITCHING                              
                              
East All Stars                    IP    H    R   ER   BB   SO   HR   BFP      
Barney Brown                       3    2    0    0    1    3    0    11      
Bill Byrd L                      1.1    4    4    3    2    0    0    11      
Jonas Gaines                     2.2    0    0    0    0    1    0     8      
Leon Day                           1    1    0    0    0    1    0     3      
Totals                             8    7    4    3    3    5    0    33      
                              
HBP: Barney Brown                               
IBB: Bill Byrd                               
                              
West All Stars                    IP    H    R   ER   BB   SO   HR   BFP      
Felix Evans                        3    1    0    0    0    2    0    10      
Dan Bankhead W                     3    1    0    0    1    3    0    12      
Johnny Williams S                  3    2    1    1    1    0    0    11      
Totals                             9    4    1    1    2    5    0    33      
                              
HBP: Dan Bankhead, Johnny Williams                               
                              
Time of Game: 2:24   Attendance: 45474                              
Retrosheet Play-by-Play Account
Game of Sunday, 8/18/1946 -- East East at West West (D)

Starting Lineups:

   East                          West                          
1. H.Kimbro            cf        A.Wilson            ss        
2. L.Doby              2b        A.Ware              1b        
3. H.Easterling        3b        S.Jethroe           cf        
4. B.Leonard           1b        P.Davis             2b        
5. M.Irvin             lf        W.Grace             rf        
6. J.Gibson            c         A.Radcliff          3b        
7. G.Benson            rf        C.Hyde              lf        
8. S.Garcia            ss        Q.Trouppe           c         
9. B.Brown             p         F.Evans             p         

EAST 1ST: H.Kimbro out on unknown play; L.Doby struck out;
H.Easterling struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 0, West 0.

WEST 1ST: A.Wilson was called out on strikes; A.Ware out on
unknown play; S.Jethroe was hit by a pitch; S.Jethroe was caught
stealing second (J.Gibson to L.Doby); 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB. 
East 0, West 0.

EAST 2ND: B.Leonard singled to center field (S.Jethroe to
A.Wilson) [B.Leonard out at second]; M.Irvin reached on an error
by C.Hyde [M.Irvin to third]; J.Gibson reached on a fielder's
choice (A.Wilson to Q.Trouppe) [M.Irvin out at home]; G.Benson
out on unknown play; 0 R, 1 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  East 0, West 0.

WEST 2ND: P.Davis struck out; W.Grace singled; W.Grace was
caught stealing second (J.Gibson to L.Doby); A.Radcliff struck
out; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 0, West 0.

EAST 3RD: S.Garcia out on unknown play; B.Brown out on unknown
play; H.Kimbro out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East
0, West 0.

WEST 3RD: C.Hyde doubled; Q.Trouppe walked; On a bunt F.Evans
popped to B.Brown; A.Wilson out on unknown play; A.Ware out on
unknown play; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  East 0, West 0.

EAST 4TH: D.BANKHEAD REPLACED F.EVANS (PITCHING); L.Doby
walked; H.Easterling out on unknown play; B.Leonard out on
unknown play; M.Irvin struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  East 0,
West 0.

WEST 4TH: B.BYRD REPLACED B.BROWN (PITCHING); S.Jethroe popped
to S.Garcia; P.Davis walked; W.Grace singled to right field
[P.Davis scored (no RBI) (error by G.Benson)]; A.Radcliff out on
a sacrifice bunt (B.Byrd to B.Leonard) [W.Grace to second];
C.Hyde singled to center field [W.Grace scored]; C.Hyde stole
second; Q.Trouppe was walked intentionally; D.Bankhead lined to
L.Doby; 2 R, 2 H, 1 E, 2 LOB.  East 0, West 2.

EAST 5TH: J.Gibson struck out; G.Benson out on unknown play;
S.Garcia was hit by a pitch; B.Byrd struck out; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 1
LOB.  East 0, West 2.

Umpires rotated: 1B to Home, 2B to 1B, 3B to 2B, Home to 3B

WEST 5TH: On a bunt A.Wilson singled to shortstop; A.Ware out
on a sacrifice bunt (B.Byrd to B.Leonard) [A.Wilson to second];
S.Jethroe reached on an error by S.Garcia [A.Wilson to third,
S.Jethroe to first]; A.Wilson stole home and S.Jethroe stole
second; P.Davis singled to center field [S.Jethroe scored
(unearned)]; J.GAINES REPLACED B.BYRD (PITCHING); W.Grace forced
P.Davis (L.Doby to S.Garcia) [W.Grace to first]; W.Grace was
caught stealing second (J.Gibson to L.Doby); 1 R (0 ER), 2 H, 1
E, 0 LOB.  East 0, West 4.

EAST 6TH: H.Kimbro out on unknown play; L.Doby singled;
H.Easterling out on unknown play; B.Leonard out on unknown play;
0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  East 0, West 4.

WEST 6TH: A.Radcliff struck out; C.Hyde out on unknown play;
Q.Trouppe out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 0,
West 4.

EAST 7TH: J.WILLIAMS REPLACED D.BANKHEAD (PITCHING); M.Irvin
out on unknown play; J.Gibson walked; G.Benson grounded into a
double play (P.Davis to A.Wilson to A.Ware) [J.Gibson out at
second]; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 0, West 4.

WEST 7TH: J.Williams out on unknown play; A.Wilson reached on
an error by S.Garcia [A.Wilson to first]; A.Ware out on a
sacrifice bunt (unknown fielder) [A.Wilson to second]; S.Jethroe
out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  East 0, West 4.

EAST 8TH: M.WATKINS BATTED FOR S.GARCIA; M.Watkins was hit by a
pitch; P.SCANTLEBURY BATTED FOR J.GAINES; P.Scantlebury singled
to center field [M.Watkins to second]; T.BUTTS RAN FOR
P.SCANTLEBURY; H.Kimbro forced T.Butts (A.Ware to A.Wilson)
[M.Watkins to third, H.Kimbro to first]; L.Doby hit into a
double play (C.Hyde to P.Davis) [M.Watkins scored, H.Kimbro out
at second]; 1 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 1, West 4.

WEST 8TH: L.DAY REPLACED M.WATKINS (PITCHING); T.BUTTS STAYED
IN GAME (PLAYING SS); P.Davis out on unknown play; W.Grace
singled; W.Grace was caught stealing second (J.Gibson to
L.Doby); A.Radcliff struck out; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  East 1,
West 4.

EAST 9TH: H.Easterling out on unknown play; B.Leonard out on
unknown play; M.Irvin singled; J.Gibson out on unknown play; 0
R, 1 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  East 1, West 4.

Final Totals      R   H   E  LOB
 East             1   4   3   5
 West             4   7   1   5

Back to Main Page for Negro League All-Star Games
Back to Main Page for Negro League Baseball

Read Me